Close-up Showdown: Nikon Z 105mm Macro Vs 50mm Macro – Which Wins?

Nikon’s Z series mirrorless cameras have been gaining popularity among photographers for their compact size, lightweight design, and powerful performance. If you’re looking to add a macro lens to your Z series camera, you’ll have to decide between the Nikon Z 105mm Macro and 50mm Macro. Both lenses offer excellent image quality, but there are some key differences between them that you should consider before you make your decision.

1. Focal Length:

The first thing to consider is the focal length of the lens. The Nikon Z 105mm Macro has a longer focal length than the 50mm Macro, which means it can capture subjects that are farther away. This is ideal for shooting small subjects that are difficult to get close to, such as insects or flowers. The 50mm Macro, on the other hand, has a shorter focal length, which makes it better suited for shooting larger subjects, such as portraits or still lifes.

2. Magnification:

The Nikon Z 105mm Macro offers a higher maximum magnification than the 50mm Macro. This means that it can capture images with more detail and clarity. The 105mm Macro can magnify subjects up to 1:1, while the 50mm Macro can only magnify subjects up to 0.5:1.

3. Working Distance:

The working distance of a lens refers to the distance between the front of the lens and the subject. The Nikon Z 105mm Macro has a longer working distance than the 50mm Macro, which means you can get closer to your subjects without disturbing them. This is especially important when shooting small insects or other delicate subjects.

4. Price:

The Nikon Z 105mm Macro is more expensive than the 50mm Macro. This is because it offers a higher maximum magnification and a longer working distance. However, the price difference between the two lenses is not significant, so it’s not a major factor to consider when making your decision.

5. Image Quality:

Both the Nikon Z 105mm Macro and 50mm Macro produce excellent image quality. They both have sharp optics and produce images with vibrant colors and fine detail. However, the 105mm Macro has a slight edge in image quality, thanks to its higher maximum magnification.

6. Autofocus:

Both the Nikon Z 105mm Macro and 50mm Macro feature autofocus. However, the 105mm Macro is faster and more accurate than the 50mm Macro. This is important for shooting moving subjects, such as insects or animals.

7. Manual Focus:

Both the Nikon Z 105mm Macro and 50mm Macro offer manual focus. However, the 105mm Macro has a more precise manual focus ring than the 50mm Macro. This makes it easier to focus on subjects that are close to the camera.

The Verdict:

So, which lens should you choose? The Nikon Z 105mm Macro is the best choice for photographers who want a lens that can capture small subjects with great detail and clarity. It also has a longer working distance, which makes it ideal for shooting delicate subjects. The Nikon Z 50mm Macro is a good choice for photographers who want a lens that is more versatile and can be used for a wider variety of subjects. It’s also less expensive than the 105mm Macro.

Frequently Asked Questions:

1. Which lens is better for shooting insects?

The Nikon Z 105mm Macro is better for shooting insects because it has a longer focal length and a higher maximum magnification. This allows you to get closer to your subjects and capture more detail.

2. Which lens is better for shooting flowers?

Either the Nikon Z 105mm Macro or the 50mm Macro can be used for shooting flowers. However, the 105mm Macro has a slight edge in image quality, thanks to its higher maximum magnification.

3. Which lens is better for shooting portraits?

The Nikon Z 50mm Macro is better for shooting portraits because it has a shorter focal length. This allows you to get closer to your subject and create a more intimate portrait.

4. Which lens is better for shooting still lifes?

Either the Nikon Z 105mm Macro or the 50mm Macro can be used for shooting still lifes. However, the 50mm Macro is a good choice for shooting larger subjects, while the 105mm Macro is better for shooting smaller subjects.

5. Which lens is better for shooting video?

The Nikon Z 105mm Macro is better for shooting video because it has a longer focal length and a higher maximum magnification. This allows you to get closer to your subjects and capture more detail.