Nikon D700 Vs Sony A58: A Detailed Comparison Review (you Won’t Believe The Differences)

In the realm of digital photography, Nikon and Sony stand as two of the most renowned brands, each offering an array of impressive DSLR cameras. Among their popular models, the Nikon D700 and Sony A58 stand out as compelling choices for photographers seeking a versatile and high-performance camera. This comprehensive comparison delves into the key features, strengths, and weaknesses of these two DSLR stalwarts, helping you make an informed decision about which one suits your photography needs and preferences.

Image Quality: Resolving the Details

Resolution is a crucial factor in determining image quality, and both the Nikon D700 and Sony A58 deliver impressive results in this regard. The D700 boasts a 12.1-megapixel CMOS sensor, while the A58 features a 20.1-megapixel Exmor APS HD CMOS sensor. While the A58’s higher megapixel count suggests an advantage in resolution, it’s essential to consider other factors that contribute to image quality.

In terms of dynamic range, the D700 excels with its ability to capture a wider range of tones and details, particularly in high-contrast scenes. This attribute is crucial for preserving highlights and shadows, resulting in more natural and visually appealing images. The A58, while capable of producing detailed images, may struggle in challenging lighting conditions due to its narrower dynamic range.

Sensor Size: A Matter of Perspective

The sensor size plays a significant role in determining the overall image quality and performance of a DSLR camera. The Nikon D700 features a larger APS-C sensor compared to the Sony A58’s smaller APS-C sensor. This difference in sensor size has several implications:

• Depth of Field Control: The larger sensor on the D700 allows for better control over the depth of field, enabling photographers to create images with beautifully blurred backgrounds, isolating their subjects with precision. The smaller sensor on the A58 may limit the ability to achieve the same level of background blur.

• Low-Light Performance: The larger sensor on the D700 also provides an advantage in low-light conditions. With its larger surface area, the D700’s sensor can gather more light, resulting in cleaner images with reduced noise at higher ISO settings. The A58, with its smaller sensor, may struggle with noise at higher ISO settings, especially in dimly lit environments.

Autofocus: Capturing the Action

Autofocus performance is a critical aspect for photographers who shoot fast-moving subjects or in dynamic situations. Both the Nikon D700 and Sony A58 offer capable autofocus systems, but each has its strengths and weaknesses:

• Nikon D700: The D700 features a 51-point autofocus system with 15 cross-type sensors, providing fast and accurate focusing even in low-light conditions. Its dedicated autofocus motor ensures precise and consistent focus tracking, making it an excellent choice for sports, wildlife, and action photography.

• Sony A58: The A58 boasts a 15-point autofocus system with three cross-type sensors. While it may not match the D700’s autofocus capabilities in terms of speed and accuracy, the A58 still delivers reliable performance for general photography and casual shooting.

Video Capabilities: Moving Beyond Stills

In the realm of video recording, the Nikon D700 and Sony A58 offer varying capabilities:

• Nikon D700: The D700 offers basic video recording capabilities, allowing users to capture 720p HD video at 24 frames per second (fps). While it may not be suitable for professional videographers, the D700 can serve as a decent option for casual video recording and vlogging.

• Sony A58: The A58 takes video recording a step further with its ability to capture 1080p Full HD video at 60 fps. This higher resolution and frame rate provide smoother and more detailed video footage, making the A58 a more compelling choice for those interested in serious video production.

Build Quality and Ergonomics: In the Hands of the Photographer

The build quality and ergonomics of a camera play a significant role in the overall user experience. Both the Nikon D700 and Sony A58 offer solid construction and comfortable handling, but there are some notable differences:

• Nikon D700: The D700 features a robust magnesium alloy body, known for its durability and weather resistance. Its larger size and weight provide a solid and stable feel in the hands, especially when paired with heavier lenses. The D700’s ergonomic design, with well-placed controls and a comfortable grip, enhances the shooting experience.

• Sony A58: The A58, while not as rugged as the D700, still offers a durable polycarbonate body with a metal chassis. Its lighter weight makes it easier to carry around, particularly for extended periods. The A58’s compact size and intuitive button layout make it suitable for photographers with smaller hands or those who prefer a more portable camera.

Battery Life: Powering Your Shots

Battery life is a crucial consideration for photographers who shoot on the go or during extended sessions. The Nikon D700 and Sony A58 differ in their battery performance:

• Nikon D700: The D700 utilizes the EN-EL3e battery, which provides a CIPA-rated battery life of approximately 1000 shots per charge. This impressive endurance makes the D700 a reliable companion for long shooting days or assignments where battery changes are impractical.

• Sony A58: The A58, on the other hand, uses the NP-FM500H battery, which offers a CIPA-rated battery life of approximately 670 shots per charge. While this is still respectable, it may fall short for photographers who require extended shooting sessions without access to power outlets.

Price and Availability: Weighing the Value

The Nikon D700 and Sony A58 occupy different price ranges, reflecting their respective features and capabilities:

• Nikon D700: The Nikon D700, being an older model, can be found at a more affordable price point compared to the Sony A58. Its discontinued status may also affect its availability, with limited stock or refurbished options available in the market.

• Sony A58: The Sony A58, as a newer model, commands a higher price tag. However, its wider availability and ongoing production make it easier to find and purchase, both new and used.

The Verdict: Choosing the Right Camera for Your Needs

The Nikon D700 and Sony A58 are both capable DSLR cameras with distinct strengths and weaknesses. The D700 excels in image quality, low-light performance, and autofocus capabilities, making it a compelling choice for professional and enthusiast photographers. The A58 offers a more compact and lightweight design, along with Full HD video recording and a user-friendly interface, making it a suitable option for hobbyists and casual photographers.

Ultimately, the best camera for you depends on your specific needs and preferences. Consider factors such as image quality, sensor size, autofocus performance, video capabilities, build quality, battery life, and price when making your decision. Whether you choose the Nikon D700 or the Sony A58, you’ll have a reliable and feature-rich DSLR camera to capture your creative vision.

Questions We Hear a Lot

1. Q: Which camera has better image quality, the Nikon D700 or the Sony A58?

• A: The Nikon D700 generally offers better image quality due to its larger sensor size, wider dynamic range, and superior low-light performance.

2. Q: Which camera has faster autofocus, the Nikon D700 or the Sony A58?

• A: The Nikon D700 features a more advanced autofocus system with 51 focus points and 15 cross-type sensors, providing faster and more accurate focusing.

3. Q: Which camera is better for video recording, the Nikon D700 or the Sony A58?

• A: The Sony A58 offers superior video capabilities, allowing users to capture 1080p Full HD video at 60 fps, while the Nikon D700 is limited to 720p HD video recording.

4. Q: Which camera is more durable and weather-resistant, the Nikon D700 or the Sony A58?

• A: The Nikon D700 features a more robust magnesium alloy body and is better suited for harsh weather conditions compared to the Sony A58’s polycarbonate body.

5. Q: Which camera has longer battery life, the Nikon D700 or the Sony A58?

• A: The Nikon D700 offers superior battery life with a CIPA-rated endurance of approximately 1000 shots per charge, while the Sony A58 provides a battery life of approximately 670 shots per charge.